Obama - is he ready to lead?
Below is the latest and brightest attempt so far by McCain to go negative on Obama. [Much better than the previous clip, which is spectacularly unfunny].
The video follows the, by now, traditional line of attack, which aims to portray Obama as glitzy, but hollow. I.e., charismatic but lacking substance. The video makes a somewhat less than subtle comparison with Britney Spears, and then makes the dooming question: Is he ready to lead?
Fair enough. From then on, however, the video becomes logically flawed. It goes on to expose two of Obama’s stances, as an illustration of the said thesis: opposition to offshore drilling, and raising electricity taxes. The idea behind this is, I think, to illustrate the prior thesis. Obama is not ready to lead because his policies are bad. Where is the flawed logic? Well, Obama, like Bush Jr., can turn out to be very good at leading. Now, whether the policies that come out of the business of leading are good or bad, is an entirely different story [or fish food, to translate a Romanian expression]. Obama can be very ready to lead, can be good at leading, and still his policies could be bad. Two different issues here, conflated by a stiff, uninspired and uninspiring McCain campaign. If I had one advice to give to McCain, that would be: hire Stephen Colbert! But, then again, his price tag might be beyond McCain’s budget.
More about this on Justin Webb’s blog.
31 Jul 2008 Skybar One 4 comments
